Skip to Content

Is It Ever a Good Idea to Let Your Tenant Sublet?

A female subletting tenant carrying boxes with personal belongings.As someone who owns rental property, you probably take great care in choosing the right tenants. At times, tenants may look to economize by renting out their space to another person, permission notwithstanding. This scenario commonly unfolds for tenants who have entered into long-term leases but will be away from their property for a long time. Opting not to cancel the lease, tenants may see subletting as a more favorable choice. The purpose of this article is to aid you in handling this issue and securing a resolution that suits all parties.

Subletting is when a tenant lets a portion of their home, for instance, a bedroom, to someone else while they still occupy it. Even though this can be a practical way for tenants to secure additional funds, it tends to cause unease for landlords. Being a property owner necessitates a careful assessment of the benefits and drawbacks of authorizing subletting by tenants. Let us examine these aspects more closely.

Who is Responsible?

Subletting is a prevalent method that occurs via two avenues. In the first scenario, a legal sublet, the landlord authorizes the tenant to lease out either the entire property or a portion of it to another tenant. The second is an illegal sublet, characterized by the tenant renting out the property to another individual without the permission of the landlord.

When it comes to subletting, bear in mind that the initial tenant holds legal accountability for upholding the lease terms and paying the rent in full. Hence, the original tenant retains the ultimate responsibility, even in scenarios where subletting is sanctioned. In the smoothest scenarios, subletting still entails a hefty trust in the original tenant to ensure their subtenant observes every term of the lease agreement.

Reasons Not to Allow Subletting

The prerogative to allow or disallow subletting is yours alone as the property manager or landlord. However, it’s significant to acknowledge that sometimes, due to homeowners’ associations or certain rules, subletting can be restricted. Should such agreements forbid subletting, this might constitute the sole basis for you to deny your tenant the option to sublet your rental unit.

You might also disallow subletting due to the challenge of rent collection if the subtenant fails to pay and your original tenant is not around. Therefore, you would be forced to chase down the original tenant for payment, which can be a lengthy and challenging process. Should the sublet prove to be illegal, accepting rent from a subtenant is crucially something to avoid. Receiving payments from a subtenant, even one subletting illegally, may unintentionally grant them rights to your property, with eviction being the only recourse to revoke these rights.

Reasons to Allow Subletting

Various landlords approve of subletting to ensure their units stay occupied. This holds true especially when a tenant is expected to be away for a significant amount of time. Preserving a positive tenant relationship is important, and facilitating them in tailoring arrangements to their requirements is a significant means to that end. Authorizing your tenant to sublet is beneficial in dodging vacancies and the costs of tenant turnover, as long as rent payment is punctual monthly.

Subletting Agreements

The optimal approach is to draft a comprehensive subletting agreement that outlines both your expectations and the obligations of your tenant. Independent of your approval of subletting, it’s critical to embed a clause in your lease that unambiguously states the permissions and their timing. With open and clear communication, misunderstandings can be bypassed, ensuring a harmonious and tension-free rental experience for both landlord and tenant.

When thinking about authorizing subletting, it’s critical to implement protective measures for both your interests and your property. A primary step involves conducting a comprehensive screening of the subletting tenant, akin to the vetting process for any prospective tenant. After locating a compatible tenant, establishing unequivocal expectations and guidelines for the subletting agreement is imperative. By formulating and ratifying a sublease agreement, you can enumerate all the stipulations and provisions of the subletting arrangement. Instituting a sublease contract can avert forthcoming issues or disagreements that might emerge.

Do you have queries on permitting your tenant to sublet your property? No worries, Real Property Management NW Indiana has got you covered! Contact us online or call 219-525-1277 to talk to a rental property expert today. Our team of pros is here to help you make the best decision for your property in Crown Point or nearby.

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.

The Neighborly Done Right Promise

The Neighborly Done Right Promise ® delivered by Real Property Management, a proud Neighborly company

When it comes to finding the right property manager for your investment property, you want to know that they stand behind their work and get the job done right – the first time. At Real Property Management we have the expertise, technology, and systems to manage your property the right way. We work hard to optimize your return on investment while preserving your asset and giving you peace of mind. Our highly trained and skilled team works hard so you can be sure your property's management will be Done Right.

Canada excluded. Services performed by independently owned and operated franchises.

See Full Details